1.24.2010

Reporting From Planet FYIGM

WPA Federal Art Project
[New York, between 1936 and 1939]
Library of Congress
Weekdays, my alarm clock is set to pre-dawn NPR, since "Morning Edition" is annoying enough to make me bolt out of bed to turn down the volume. Once I'm up, I have to keep the sound on, to stay aware of the time while I struggle to get ready for work and out the door.

If I were a retired old fogey with ample free time—instead of an OF who can expect to work until dropping—there would be daily fodder for writing indignant e-mails to the network.

Some segments particularly stand out for egregiousness, and I always mean to check out those transcripts. But as I'm also running late and about to spend 8 hours having my brains sucked out—by the time I remember to look at NPR's site, I can rarely find the right date or segment.

But this Friday I had to make a point of looking for this.

An installment of the grating "Planet Money" series informs us that the proposed "Cadillac tax"
is a tax on the most expensive health care plans. Executives with gold-plated plans don't like it and neither do labor unions, whose workers have generous plans. But many economists say it could help everyone in the long run.
To illustrate the "he said/she said, but an expert will settle this" principle, the reporters take this $43,000 a year call center worker ...
I have asthma and I've had it since I was probably 10, 12 years old. And it seems to be progressively getting worse. I pay over $1,500 a year for my medication. And I need those medications to live. And I heard some senators wanted to tax our health care benefits. I just couldn't believe it.
... and introduce her to a university economist. Because, according to these crack reporters—
DAVID KESTENBAUM: Economists on this issue feel lonely, sad and very misunderstood.
CHANA JOFFE-WALT: Well, yeah, because economists use math and charts to make their arguments. Labor unions use emotion and advertisements featuring sympathetic characters with asthma.
There will be no pausing to ask why the medication should cost $1,500 a year.

The ensuing exchange between worker and economist is grotesque.

Ms. Stanley, who is worried about sheer survival, is assured by Professor Stearns that her costs would go up, but only if AT & T keeps her current, expensive plan. Which they surely won't do—they will switch to a cheaper plan, using the savings to give her a raise.

Among the most painful parts—
Ms. STANLEY: They are not going to give us I'm at top wage, right now. Only cost I get - only wage increase I get is the cost of living.
Prof. STEARN: But they are getting something in return. If you were to say to them, we are willing to give up $8000 of health insurance benefits, then I don't see any reason why they wouldn't be willing to do that.
Ms. STANLEY [Panic rising in her voice]: No, they're not, it's not the way it works in bargaining at all. I know they are not going to give me that.
JOFFE-WALT: What is your proof, though, how do you know that is not going to happen?
Ms. STANLEY: That hasn't changed for 18 years.
JOFFE-WALT: Economists are convinced that this will happen. They say there's lots of data showing when employers pay more for health benefits, they pay less in wages. So, it should work in reverse. Less in benefits, more money to wages.
At first, I take the increasingly strangled tone of the worker's voice to be due to terror, as she comes to realize she's been ambushed into talking about her employer on national radio. But as she's in a union, she may have some protection against retaliation.

Then, I decide her tone must really be from frustration at trying to get through to someone so divorced from reality he has to be told that passing savings to workers is "not the way it works."

Not only can he not comprehend, he clearly thinks she is the stupid one—
Prof. STEARN: When was the last time you had a medical emergency?
Ms. STANLEY: I went to the ER seven years ago when I broke my arm.
Prof. STEARN: It sounds like you don't need the health benefit plan that you have. On the whole, my guess is you're losing money on your health insurance. You would benefit from having a worse health benefit plan and taking that extra money and getting higher wages.
Ms. STANLEY: I disagree.
Prof. STEARN: But you should change your mind.
The patronizing of this woman by NPR and its "expert"—the type whose abstractions have done so much to endorse the turning of this country into what we are now—is infuriating. As usual, Upton Sinclair's observation applies: "It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it."

I'm still steaming about the tenured jerk, who sounds completely sincere—he seems to have no agenda beyond promoting post-Reagan conventional thinking (and he might very well be comfortable voting Democratic). A man so expert, he can ignore all of the last 30 years to claim that corporate savings will go to raising wages of ordinary drudges. When it's a fucking wonder that AT&T hasn't outsourced this woman's call center to India yet.

I've been working on my plan of starting the year by reading about Great Depression topics.

And looking at WPA art: there's some wonderful stuff that I plan to post over the coming months. But it's also a painful reminder of how far we've been pushed from public expenditures being allowed to benefit the public. And of how we've entered a fourth decade when distribution of wealth upward is the unquestioned norm.

This week, the starter gun was fired for corporate money to take control of all elected offices outright.

And this week was the anniversary of Obama's inauguration. A year ago, but feeling light years away in terms of the possibilities that had seemed to exist, at the time. Not that any sane person expected a magic wand to be waved. But some of us did expect movement in a good direction—instead of a year of wasted time and one-sided "bipartisanship," all while the right tastes blood and acts accordingly.

Corporations will not be subjected to laws by a government they own. But there will be increasingly harsh ones—including "economic laws"—for all of us surplus humanity who have to live on the real Planet Money, locked down by its rulers, Corporate Persons.

1.17.2010

The Context

Because it won't be in the mainstream reporting about unimaginable disaster and suffering, there's all that background about the libertarian paradise of sweatshop labor crowded into Port-Au-Prince, where there are no real building codes...

A quick review of over two centuries of U.S-Haiti history, from Robert Parry.

Max Blumenthal's 2004 piece, "The other regime change," on the Bush Administration's role in the ouster of Jean-Bertrand Aristide. Blumenthal covers the Haitian activities of the International Republican Institute, funded by taxpayers through USAID. And the official Bush point man on Haiti—because nothing says concern for the welfare of an impoverished black nation than delegating policy to a Jesse Helms aide.

The usual suspects lose no time during the current devastation.

Within hours of the earthquake, Naomi Klein finds something "hastily yanked by the Heritage Foundation and replaced with a more diplomatic quote, but their first instinct is revealing"—
In addition to providing immediate humanitarian assistance, the U.S. response to the tragic earthquake in Haiti earthquake offers opportunities to re-shape Haiti's long-dysfunctional government and economy as well as to improve the public image of the United States in the region.
With all those profits from his crooked, tax-exempt empire, mega-millionaire Pat Robertson must know all about deals with the devil more real than this usual piece of shtick.

And Limbaugh, just back from compassionate, unionized and near-socialized Hawaiian medical care, is busy telling his fans to ignore the fuss about worthless, poor blacks.

Yes, the publicity is negative, so "responsible" conservatives make a show of criticizing them. But so long as Robertson, Limbaugh and the like are alive and breathing hot air, nothing will remove them from their media platforms.

Nothing to counterbalance these ghouls, except for giving something to aid groups, and hoping they can get through before more lives are lost.

1.01.2010

Putting The "Great" In Great Depression...

...WPA art!
Library of Congress WPA/Federal Art Project [NY] - 1939 calendar Artist: Harry Herzog
... Something I plan to visit more of this year.

12.31.2009

December 2009: The Not-So-Great Depression

failblog.org
As Clever Sister has long said, we've had an economic depression for years—only it's been masked by credit card spending, something not available to the masses during the 1930s.

The old image of investors jumping out windows—it does seem somewhat fitting, at least compared to how many people of the non-investor class will probably be victims of a new upswing in murder-suicides, domestic violence, and workplace shootings.

Though according to this, the idea that the rich reacted to the Depression by suicide is mainly mythical, planted in the public mind—and histories—because of a few highly publicized incidents.

Having a government that responded to that particular depression was in the end a reality. And it tends to make me long for the good old, bad days—before the possibility of real discussion was suppressed, so that nothing important can ever be put "on the table" in our own time.

Thom Hartmann often plays clips of F. D. Roosevelt's 1936 speeches at the Democratic Convention in June, and at Madison Square Garden, just before Election Day.

From the convention speech transcript–
Against economic tyranny such as this, the American citizen could appeal only to the organized power of Government. The collapse of 1929 showed up the despotism for what it was. The election of 1932 was the people's mandate to end it. Under that mandate it is being ended.

The royalists of the economic order have conceded that political freedom was the business of the Government, but they have maintained that economic slavery was nobody's business...They granted that the Government could protect the citizen in his right to vote, but they denied that the Government could do anything to protect the citizen in his right to work and his right to live.

...

These economic royalists complain that we seek to overthrow the institutions of America. What they really complain of is that we seek to take away their power. Our allegiance to American institutions requires the overthrow of this kind of power. In vain they seek to hide behind the Flag and the Constitution. In their blindness they forget what the Flag and the Constitution stand for. Now, as always, they stand for democracy, not tyranny; for freedom, not subjection; and against a dictatorship by mob rule and the over-privileged alike.
And from the October speech—
Never before in all our history have these forces been so united against one candidate as they stand today. They are unanimous in their hate for me—and I welcome their hatred.

I should like to have it said of my first Administration that in it the forces of selfishness and of lust for power met their match. I should like to have it said of my second Administration that in it these forces met their master.
No wonder he was hated by the wealthy. And no wonder they have worked relentlessly ever since, to become as safe in their ownership of government as they are today.

By now, they've also suceeding in making workers pretty much invisible.

Or at least until Republicans need to fake some populism—like thrusting "Joe" the "Plumber" into the media...

After "Joe" is set up in his latest incarnation—as "war correspondent"—Hartmann makes a point of inteviewing "Joe" about the real "areas of his expertise." [Not-to-be-missed audio here.]

And there's the other current fake populism: corporate lobbyist-financed teabagger rallies, where Medicare recipients demand that the gubmint lay off their health care.

While workers suffering from the lack of medical attention they can't afford have to line up for a rare chance like this.

But our media prefers reporting on those exciting rallies, with their dozens of "real people."

We've had a year of political pretense that bi-partisanism and post-racism are real. In other words, a year of lost opportunities.

A Department of Justice staying packed by the Bush administration.

The power of life and death over healthcare-deprived Americans being granted to Joe Lieberman.

There's no new New Deal in the works. Tragically mistaken, but completely predictable, given how far rightward acceptable discourse has been driven over the last thirty years. When Thom Hartmann broadcast from Denmark last January, he noted that the local conservative politicians were mystified by how right-wing Obama is. This researcher found the same reaction in Norway.

While the rest of the economy collapses, one commodity is booming: right-wing violence.

A women's health care provider can be gunned down in church, and the media label the victim, "Abortion Doctor." Both implied and direct messages being that it was only natural for there to have been strong feeling against him. Or, it could be said: he asked for it.

At least NYT readers took the paper to task over its shameful coverage.

And business is booming for right-wing propagandists.

They don't get the fabulous pay of the wingnut class, but the writers at Sadly, No persevere in cutting the right-wing pundits down to size.

From this Spring, as the right howled over DHS' release of its report on right-wing violence, is Gavin M.'s summary of a screed by right-wing blogger Ed Morrissey—
It is ridiculous to blame Bush for commissioning the DHS report, because while the Bush administration might have wanted an assessment of right-wing extremist threats, it would not necessarily have wanted one that blamed it on right-wing extremism.
Gavin adds a footnote—
We've switched Ed's favorite coffee with Eric Rudolph, Timothy McVeigh and Terry Nichols, James Adkisson, Michael F. Griffin, Chad "The Michelle Malkin Anthrax Fraudster" Castagana, John "Dirty Bomb" Cummings, Richard Poplawski, Donald Cooper, Paul Jennings Hill, Tharin Robert Gartrell and associates, David McMenemy, Albert Brock, Francisco Martin Duran, Frank Eugene Corder, John Salvi, Japes Kopp, Bradley T. Kahle, Clayton Waagner, Martin Uphoff, Chad Altman, Shelley Shannon, Timothy Dale Johnson, Buford Furrow, probably some others that we're forgetting, a scheme by Georgia wingnuts to kill Mexican people with machine guns; numerous unknown arsonists, bombers, assailants, and killers, possibly including the Leahy/Daschle anthrax terrorist; assorted anti-government militias; let's not even get into the whole Aryan Nations thing; and last and also pretty much least, Matthew Derosia, who rammed an SUV into an abortion clinic in January '09, in Ed's own demesne of St. Paul, MN. Let's see if he notices!
It's just a routine bit of brilliance from S, N.

As the decade ends—or at least, the atrocious aughts finish—it's Jonah Goldberg who gets a million dollar book deal.

12.29.2009

December 2008: Exits

Exit, shredding.
Cheney snowglobe; from Philip Toledano's America, The Giftshop
Well, it is something that distinguishes our guys from the Nazis—who were so proud of their recordkeeping.

Exit, admitting on teevee to authorizing torture.

Exit, ducking. As an Iraqi journalist speaks for millions. An event later commemorated (if not for long).

The shoes being the first honest statement made in Bush's presence since this.

A Sadly, No reader posts the news of Bush's Baghdad presser in this thread. Commenter Smut Clyde will respond, "The insurgency is in its last throws."

Though the shoes might have been served as a contribution to the wardrobe—after all, it takes great effort to clothe a naked emperor.

And our free press does go all out to join in the effort.
By next month, there will be the bizarre performance at his last press conference—
I've thought long and hard about Katrina -- you know, could I have done something differently, like land Air Force One either in New Orleans or Baton Rouge. The problem with that and -- is that law enforcement would have been pulled away from the mission. And then your questions, I suspect, would have been, how could you possibly have flown Air Force One into Baton Rouge, and police officers that were needed to expedite traffic out of New Orleans were taken off the task to look after you?
He really believes a photo op would have made everything right.
Of all that was unleased in NOLA, there are still horror stories coming to light only now.

Just this month, Nation writer A.C. Thompson's Katrina's Hidden Race War tells of white vigilantee terror. Including murders, committed with impunity, and with apparent police involvement.
More exits, more players...

Exit, removing inconveniences. "Rove's IT Guru" is killed in the crash of the small plane he had flown for years.

Connell had been warned of possible plane sabotage. And he had been been ordered to testify in Ohio lawyer Cliff Arnebeck's suit alleging Connell's 2004 role in flipping votes from Kerry to Bush.

Exit, stealing. The well-connected are kept busy with the final looting of treasury.

Exit, avoiding prosecution. The lot of them.

It's over a year old, but this from driftglass may be the ultimate punchline of the joke that's been played on the country all these years.

Along with driftglass' corollary punchline:
100 years from now, historians will say that, after eight years of lavishing attention on every ginned-up, half-baked, crackpot, wingnut-financed Clinton rumor, the media felt real, real bad about how awfully they'd behaved and decided to make it up...

...to George W. Bush.

December 2007: What Arte Said


"Very interestingk...
But a Mein Kampf it wasn't."
The writers at Sadly, No have been slipped an advance copy of a book long anticipated. And long mocked: as if its insane theme weren't enough, its author has also missed his publication date by over two years, while using his blog to beg readers to do his research for him.

A few months ago, Jon Swift offered Jonah Goldberg a modest proposal for tackling his theme, "Liberal Fascism"—as explained by LOLcats.

Whenever a meme being pushed by the right reaches new heights of absurdity, someone on S, N will suggest that Peak Wingnut has been reached. Which is immediately countered by the other school of thought: that There Is No Such Thing As Peak Wingnut, which is an endlessly renewable resource.

S, N posts a series on the booklike object, inspiring weeks of mockery of a target that could not be more deserving.

Among the mockery (and LOLcats): here, here, here, and here.

"Revisionism" is such a mild term.

Among other S, N posts deconstructing the book's contents—Joseph McCarthy: Man of the Left.

Using the Hitler-moustached smiley face of the book's cover, Mister Leonard Pierce takes Goldberg's claims that Mussolini was a "socialist," and rates them on a scale of one to five ("an A-bomb of idiocy") Hitler-smileys.

In "The Dread Face Of Liberal Fascism" Brad writes—
Let’s recap what we know about liberal fascists:
• Much like the Nazis, their ranks are teeming with homosexuals.
• Much like the Nazis, they enjoy bossing people around.
• And worst of all, liberal fascists just love lecturing others on the value of (shudder) exercise and nutrition. Just like THE NAZIS DID.
So to find Liberal Fascism’s Grand Führer, we must find someone who’s gay*, bossy and fitness-obsessed. And then it hit me...
Funny stuff, but of course the real point of Goldberg's text is in this part of S, N's takedown—
Believe it or not, we're about to reach the part where he identifies Progressivism itself as fascist. As in, the end of child labor, the forty-hour work-week, the founding of America's national parks — in short, all that totalitarian goose-stepping stuff that interferes with the natural order of human society, i.e. feudalism under the ministry of robber barons.
Goldberg deserves to be made the laughingstock that he is here. But he will undeservedly have platforms in Serious Venues. Such as the LA Times—which dumps Robert Scheer and replaces him with Goldberg.

If there were any doubt about how low we've sunk—the media will push Goldberg's book as a serious work, when thirty years ago his notions would have been considered the fringiest of lunacy.

Though it's clear that the right has long tried to push this stuff. The Wiki entry on the New Deal and corporatism quotes Reagan telling Time in 1976: "Fascism was really the basis for the New Deal. It was Mussolini's success in Italy, with his government-directed economy, that led the early New Dealers to say 'But Mussolini keeps the trains running on time.'"

Thom Hartmann quotes a re-write of portions of Mein Kampf, as done by Ann Coulter [or fill in the name of any other right-wing pundit]. This version substituting "the Liberals" for "the Jews."

There are people with first-hand knowledge of the Nazis who are still around, horrified by the current parallels, and speaking out.

Historian Fritz Stern.

Former Nuremberg War Crimes Tribunal prosecutor Benjamin Ferencz continues to speak and write on the rule of law.

And there are still surviving generations with close links. Ray McGovern writes on December 27, 2007—
...Sebastian Haffner (pen name for Raimund Pretzel)... as a young lawyer in Berlin during the 1930s experienced the Nazi takeover and wrote a first-hand account. His children found the manuscript when he died in 1999 and published it the following year as "Geschichte eines Deutschen" (The Story of a German).

The book became an immediate bestseller and has been translated into 20 languages—in English as "Defying Hitler."

I recently learned from his daughter Sarah, an artist in Berlin, that today is the 100th anniversary of Haffner's birth. She had seen an earlier article in which I quoted her father and e-mailed to ask me to "write some more about the book and the comparison to Bush's America. ... This is almost unbelievable."
Unlike Goldberg's doorstop, this is a succinct guide to how fascism really manifests itself. Which is looking all too familiar, with Britt's signs constantly being illustrated.

Just one recent example—revelations of the CIA's destruction of torture evidence, along with past and current obstruction of justice by US Attorneys, Mukasey, and the White House.

The fascist marriage of corporation and state is in plain sight, and in gruesome detail. Former KBR/Halliburton employee in Baghdad, Jamie Leigh Jones testifies before the House Judiciary Committee this month. Since July 2005 she's pursued justice, after her gang-rape by other contractors—immediately followed by the company's destroying evidence and imprisoning Jones in a shipping container.

Jones also testifies that eleven other women have contacted her with similar stories.

During the hearing, Congressman Robert Scott says that the Department of Justice "can enforce with respect to contractors who commit crimes abroad, but it chooses not to."

The DOJ fails to send a representative to the hearing.

The Washington Post publishes a particularly bizarre piece it presents as a human interest story: a Vietnamese immigrant who repays her gratitude to the US as "bomb lady" weapons designer. Among her quotes: "A war fighter needs to know one of three things: Do I let him go? Keep him? Or shoot him on the spot? In Vietnam, our guys didn't have this tool."

Noticing the Post's lack of comment on its "shoot...on the spot" quote, Robert Parry decides to fill the story in a bit more, with, Mobile Labs to Target Iraqis for Death. In which Parry also notes of the Post story—
Similarly, U.S. newspapers have consigned stories about U.S. troops engaging in extrajudicial killings of suspects mostly to pages deep inside the newspapers or have covered the news sympathetically. While some harsh criticism has fallen on trigger-happy Blackwater "security contractors," U.S. troops have been given largely a free pass.
And we have our political imprisonments.

There's a scene in "The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp," where Anton Walbrook's refugee character is questioned by English immigration officials. He describes life in Germany after WWI, until the Nazis came to power—
After the war years crime was increasing, and the honest citizens were having a hard job to put the gangsters in jail. Well, I needn't tell you, sir, that in Germany the gangsters finally succeeded in putting the honest citizens in jail.

12.26.2009

December 2006: Hillbillies And Other People Of The Year

hillbillybento.com
Given responsibility to arrange catering for the year-end faculty bash, Jesus' Best Administrative Assistant chose someone from her neck of the boondocks.

Party time approaches, with no sign of food delivery.

Jesus' BAA makes a frantic call to the caterer...

Who done wrote the wrong day on his calendar.

Clever Sister, who long worked in the food biz, raises virtual eyebrows—
OMG!!!!! That's something!
Did they run out to the 7-11 to get some vittles?
The lunch is moved to the next day, when the guy promises there will be much wonderous comping.

"Bologna & velveeta? Stuck on frilly toothpicks?" asks CS.

Time has met the Person of The Year, and it is Us.

watertiger agrees that she is the Average American—
1. I'm adamantly against the war.
2. I think George Bush is a criminal failure who should be impeached.
3. I hold down at least 2 (well, 3, if you count the blogging) jobs to keep ahead of the cost of living.
And so on.

whitehouse.org captures the quality of year-end reporting. The bloodthirstiness and triumphalism around Saddam Hussein's execution, here and here.

And of the tears shed over another death—Remembering Gerry Ford: President Bush Mourns Loss of Innovative Bestower of Felony-Erasing Pardons.

In other predictable events, the Frat Boy-In-Chief sneers at a persistent reporter: "It's bad in Iraq. That help?"

And baits Senator-elect Jim Webb about his son serving in Iraq. This, after being asked to be especially sensitive, because of the son's recent, narrow escape from death.

Not a circumstance Bush could conceivably have had anything to do with.